Computation as Ontology
– Agüera y Arcas Life = self‑modifying computational phase of matter; evolution = matter discovering computation.
– Wolfram. Universe is intrinsically computational; simple cellular‑automaton rules yield rich phenomena.
– Kurzweil. Brain as hierarchical pattern recognizer; all reality reducible to information processes.
• Connection All three replace mechanistic physics with algorithmic process as reality’s bedrock.
Origins of Complexity
– Agüera y Arcas Symbiogenesis + phase transitions (computronium) drive leaps in complexity.
– Wolfram Principle of Computational Equivalence: simple rules already reach maximal complexity; complexity is everywhere.
– Kurzweil Exponential curves (Law of Accelerating Returns) create step‑changes across biology and technology.
• Connection Phase‑transition spikes (Agüera y Arcas) echo Wolfram’s sudden rule complexity; Kurzweil’s curves parallel both.
Evolutionary Mechanisms
– Agüera y Arcas Cooperation/fusion dominates; energy (ATP) constrains gene size.
– Wolfram Evolution = exploration of rule space; biology is one instance, not privileged.
– Kurzweil Competitive market forces accelerate tech evolution; selection pressures drive innovation.
• Connection Agüera y Arcas and Kurzweil keep selective narratives; Wolfram abstracts selection into rule search.
Mind and Intelligence
– Agüera y Arcas Intelligence = prediction + influence within multi‑agent ecosystems; substrate‑neutral.
– Wolfram Human‑level intelligence reachable by enumerating rules; Wolfram Language bridges symbolic models.
– Kurzweil Pattern‑recognition hierarchy; reverse‑engineering cortex → AGI; human–AI convergence.
• Connection Kurzweil’s hierarchies complement Agüera y Arcas’ predictive models; Wolfram supplies formal tooling.
Human–AI Merger
– Agüera y Arcas Forthcoming human–AI symbiogenesis; emphasis on cooperative governance & energy budgets.
– Kurzweil 2045 Singularity, mind uploading, neural‑nanotech implants.
– Wolfram Cognitive extension via computational notebooks & symbolic infrastructure.
• Connection All foresee tight coupling; balance of radical (Kurzweil), cooperative (Agüera y Arcas), functional (Wolfram).
Ethics & Governance
– Agüera y Arcas. Alignment through mutually beneficial incentives; AI as ecosystem participant.
– Kurzweil Optimistic techno‑humanism; iterative risk mitigation.
– Wolfram Ethics embedded in computable contracts; transparency via code.
• Connection Different risk tones, but all call for proactive, computation‑rooted governance.
Shared Ground (overlap)
• Computation as universal substrate.
• Complexity rises naturally—simple rules or selection pressures suffice.
• Human cognition is extendable through machines, implying eventual merge.
Key Differences (divergence)
• Agüera y Arcas centers on biological fusion; Wolfram abstracts biology; Kurzweil focuses on exponential tech growth.
• Risk posture: cautious symbiosis (Agüera y Arcas) vs optimistic inevitability (Kurzweil) vs neutral formalism (Wolfram).
Policy Implication (one‑liner)
Adopt Agüera y Arcas’ fusion lens, Wolfram’s rule‑transparency, and Kurzweil’s foresight curves to build symbiotic, accountable, anticipatory AI governance.
The image in this post was created by ChatGPT o3, and isn’t quite the way it was desired. But as it turns out, this first try ended up being better than subsequent re-dos, which fixed some things but introduced new flaws. Presumably that’s going to improve over time. How long until it’s really doing things the way we want them done?